BootHole Patches Causing Many Systems to Become Unbootable
It appears that the patches released for Linux distributions in response to the GRUB2 bootloader vulnerability are causing problems for many users, making their systems unbootable.
The flaw, tracked as BootHole and CVE-2020-10713, impacts PCs, servers and other devices running Linux and Windows if they use Secure Boot. An attacker with admin privileges on the targeted system can exploit the vulnerability to run malicious code when the device boots up, enabling them to install stealthy and persistent malware.
Completely patching BootHole is not an easy task as it will involve replacing vulnerable bootloaders and updating the Secure Boot revocation list (DBX) to ensure that the old bootloaders cannot be executed, a process that requires collaboration between multiple software and hardware vendors.
Linux distributions have already started releasing updates for the grub2, shim and other packages in response to the vulnerability. However, it appears that those packages have been causing problems for many users, resulting in their systems hanging during the boot process.
Red Hat users were the first to report problems, but it appears that other Linux distributions are experiencing similar issues, including Ubuntu, Debian, CentOS and Mint.
Security researcher Kevin Beaumont reported that major cloud providers such as Azure and Digital Ocean are also seeing systems that fail to boot due to the patches.
“I think there is a genuine conversation to be had about security vulnerabilities and the wider outlook. A primary concern with security (and in business) is availability. As an industry we also need to be better at careful analysis of vulnerabilities, and staggered testing of patches. The provided solution has again, unfortunately, become worse than the vulnerability for most people,” Beaumont noted.
Impacted Linux distributions are working on developing new packages and some of them have provided instructions on how users can restore systems impacted by the buggy patches.
Capsule8’s Kelly Shortridge predicted after BootHole was disclosed, “We might see more damage from people attempting the mitigation rather than attackers leveraging this in dastardly digital crimes.”